Dr Jiang’s thoughts on treating the exterior

Lao YeYe

Like so many foreigners, soon after I first got to  Taiwan I experienced the joy of illness in a strange land. The lungs are my weak organ system, and given the Brillo pad atmosphere of Taipei, intensely cold AC mixed with murky heat and subtropic humidity, and stress of calling a very foreign country “home” it is not surprising that I came down with one frighteningly nasty respiratory condition.

It is hard enough to stand outside oneself and get enough perspective on how to treat your own condition, and it is even worse when your Americanized “pinyin-speak” rings nothing but confusion into the ears of the local herb store laoban. Luckily a friend, who was also there to study medicine, suggested we go to see this “old doctor” that a friend had recommended. We rode the subway to the “Eternal Harmony” district in search of a cure for my uncommon cold.

Like most Taiwanese clinics it is a storefront affair. Sandwiched in between a tiny lumber shop and bakery on a scooter littered sidewalk we found Dr. Jiang’s clinic, took a number and waited on the bowling alley-like plastic chairs. The TV blared pop Taiwanese music and news. I thought for sure I was going to end up in some hospital.

What little language study I had had in the States was completely useless in Taiwan. Classroom mandarin and real life full tilt language are two completely different animals. My friend translated my discomfort and fever to Doc Jiang. He wrote notes in what I would later come to recognize as a grass style type calligraphy, even the Taiwanese have a hard time reading his writing. I understood nothing of the exchange. It was his assistant that helped me to translate the formula into a language I could understand. And when I did I thought for sure this old doc should have been put out to pasture years ago.

What he prescribed was nothing like I’d been taught in school.

Doc Jiang’s idea of treating a Taiwanese cold was to prescribe, in granule form, five different complete formulas, which were then modified with several single herbs. Had I come up with a formula like that at school I would have had my tuition refunded. I considered flushing those herbs down the toilet, but then figured I was in Taiwan to learn something new about medicine. That this doc’s formula was off my radar was not necessarily a bad a thing. It was just…different…and different is no fun when you are sick. I took the herbs and went to sleep. Slept through the night, and woke the next day feeling 80% better and coughing slippery, wet phlegm from my lungs. I’m the guy who gets the dry cough. Clearly, this doc had a perspective that was worth exploring.

In the years that followed, I would spend a lot of time with Dr. Jiang. I came to find that his way of using herbs was a cross between what he learned from his father on the mainland, and the Japanese influence that is so intertwined with Taiwanese culture.

I came to see that he used formulas much how we would think of individual herbs. And that when treating almost any condition that involved the respiratory system he would see there being some kind of tai yang involvement. There were five herbs that he liked to use to resolve the exterior and clear toxin: jing jie, fang feng, bai zhi, yu xing cao, and a little bitty pinch of xi xin. This was added to any formula that he used to treat colds or allergies. In his way of thinking, opening the exterior would open the Lung. Indeed, there were many cases where I would have focused on clearing Lung heat, or nourishing Lung fluids, but he would simply resolved the exterior and give the qi mechanism a little push. The patient’s own zheng qi would take over and set them right. Elegant!

11 Responses to Dr Jiang’s thoughts on treating the exterior
  1. Jason BlalackNo Gravatar
    September 3, 2009 | 9:58 am

    Care to share the formula he gave you?

    -Jason

  2. Michael MaxNo Gravatar
    September 3, 2009 | 10:33 am

    Sure. It was a combination of:
    xing su san
    qing bi tang
    xin yi san
    shi shen tang
    the five herbs mentioned in this posting
    qian hu and chuan bei mu

    wild, huh?

  3. Dan BenskyNo Gravatar
    September 5, 2009 | 1:39 pm

    This kind of stuff is great! Let’s see if I have this correctly — something for cool-dryness, exterior cold with qi dynamic dysfunction, sinus congestion from a couple of perspectives, along with more for the exterior and for phlegm. Close?

  4. Michael MaxNo Gravatar
    September 6, 2009 | 4:16 pm

    Yes, that is pretty much it. What was surprising is how well it broke up dry phlegm.
    It took me a while to grasp how he was using multiple formulas as a single entities in a prescription. I don’t think Jiang uses it as a shotgun approach, although it certainly looks that way on first glance. Like with any formula, the more precise we are with diagnosing the underlying patho-mechanism and crafting a prescription to fit it, the more effective the treatment will be.

    It is very different from the way that Huang works. I use both methods. Both require precision. Both have their unique view of how to treat.

  5. Geoff HudsonNo Gravatar
    September 10, 2009 | 12:23 pm

    Hi Michael – welcome to Missouri. A friend of mine, Dave in Seattle, said you were moving to this neck of the woods. Did Dr. Jiang give a full dosage of the individual formulas or a small percentage of each to come up to the 10g tid (or whatever the ‘standard’ might be)?

  6. Michael MaxNo Gravatar
    September 10, 2009 | 12:38 pm

    @ Geoff Thanks, I’ve rather enjoyed working here in the Show-Me state. I’ve found a lot of openness to Chinese medicine and rather enjoy the honest skepticism that many people have. I’d much rather hear “Will this stuff really work?”, than “I believe in acupuncture.” Do come by should you make it here to the big city.

    As to Doc Jiang’s formula. He would generally write it as 4 or 5 grams of whatever formula, followed by 2-3 grams of a single herb. His herb girls would take that multiply by 5 (People can get five days of granulated herbs as part of Taiwan’s national healthcare. Yes, they have a kick ass single payer single payer system AND they are a thriving democracy. Often with voter turnouts of 70% and above. Just in case you happen to think that single payer healthcare = socialism), then they would just eyeball the amounts and scoop up the granules with plastic spoons from some restaurant down the street. The herbs would then all be mixed together, and then put into a nifty machine that would seal them into individual packets, so people can easily carry their herbs around with them.

  7. Geoff HudsonNo Gravatar
    September 11, 2009 | 12:00 pm

    I think you’ll find the honest skepticism here applies to people’s response to Western as well as Chinese medicine – which I like a lot (as opposed to sheep). Many of the ornery old buggers out in the country can be the best patients once you explain what is going on (which they aren’t used to from allopaths, and why compliance is low as well).

    With Dr. Jiang’s formulas, would that be 4 to 5 gm total of the formulas (plus modifications) he wanted to prescribe, or of each he was giving (i.e., 1gm of qing bi tang, 1g xing su tang, etc to total 4-5g vs. 4-5g of qing bi, 4-5g of xing su, etc)?

    Taiwanese politics is definitely entertaining, and occasionally a contact sport, as seen on TV!

  8. Michael MaxNo Gravatar
    November 22, 2009 | 7:13 pm

    He was giving about 3-4 gm’s per day. He would write up the ratio’s of what he wanted and then his “herb girls” would eyeball the amounts, stir up, and then toss it into the bagging machine. (they have these very nice Rube Goldberg machines that will take the granulated herbs and package them into easy to carry plastic bags that you just tear open)

  9. Mike MathersNo Gravatar
    October 27, 2011 | 11:00 pm

    Hi Michael,

    I’m in Taiwan at the moment and would love to go see Dr. Jiang while I’m here. Can you leave his contact info? And is it Jiang1 or Jiang4? A phone number would be good enough…I can read Chinese so I hope to have no problems finding the place.

  10. Michael MaxNo Gravatar
    October 28, 2011 | 11:10 am

    Mike-
    Sorry to say that Doctor Jiang passed away last winter. He was well over 100 years old.

  11. AlasdairNo Gravatar
    November 8, 2011 | 5:54 am

    Interesting, it would be useful to know what the strength ratio (fresh to granules) was. Most granules are 6:1 so he would have been giving you the equivalent of an 18-20g fresh prescription per day even at 10:1 still only 30 – 40g. Given that it was a combination of 4 classic formulae and 7 other herbs you would have been taking almost microscopic dosages of some herbs. Wild!! Shame that the good doctor has died. I hope that someone has inherited the knowledge. He must have been a diagnostician of the first order. I suspect his way of thinking could be applied to the construction of single formulae, sounds like pre-communist classical TCM working with the body, rather than beating the disease into submission.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL http://classicformulas.com/doctor-jiang/trackback/